Thursday, 15 March 2007

COMMENT: Security in Schools

This week, the Post's News Editor Andrew Wander reflects on security in schools. Is it really in the best interests of the students?

Half a million pounds. It’s a huge sum of money. Enough, in fact, to pay the salaries of nearly 20 new teachers or buy 15 minibuses. It would pay for countless school trips or could be used to buy a library with 50,000 volumes.

The Petchey Academy, due to open within months, is spending half a million pounds on security measures. The school will be guarded 24 hours a day, operate a sophisticated CCTV network and students will need to use a swipe card to move from building to building.

The school’s management team say the measures are a necessary precaution for an inner-London school. Hackney, they say, is a crime hotspot, and a school would be mad to risk falling victim to the assorted vandals, drug dealers and other undesirables that inhabit the borough.

But what effect does education in Fort Knox have on a student? Rather than growing up as part of society, this type of measure encourages children to view the wider world as a dangerous place - somewhere that is threatening and unpredictable.

How can students grow up to feel part of a society that is locked out at the school gates? What hope can Hackney have of fostering a community spirit when the next generation of residents spend their formative years in an atmosphere where any outsider is considered a suspect.

Rather than spending half a million pounds on expensive security measures, why not deal with the undoubted problems that Hackney suffers head on. Instead of a camera recording the pupils going about their daily business, why not spend the money on lunchtime supervisors - local people who are invited into the academy to keep an eye on the children during breaks.

Instead of swipe cards (which are notoriously easy to evade), why not simply ask pupils and staff to be aware of strangers on the site. A determined criminal is not going to be put off by a three-foot gate.

If children grow up in an atmosphere where security is something imposed upon them remotely, how will they ever learn to take responsibility for their own security and that of their community?

It is too easy to blame an antisocial act on the security “system” failing. The truth is that antisocial behaviour is symptomatic of the social “system” failing. This failure can only be addressed by encouraging young people to take responsibility for their own safety. No amount of money can buy community spirit, but half a million pounds could go a long way to fostering a sense of shared responsibility.

Copyright of The Hackney Post

No comments: